Friday, February 15, 2008

Friday in Lent 1

Do you not know that you are God’s temple and that God’s Spirit dwells in you? If anyone destroys God’s temple, God will destroy that person. For God’s temple is holy, and you are that temple. (1 Corinthians 3:16-17)

Here's one way of looking at the torture debate. Is is all right to waterboard the temple of God?

Is it all right to leave depleted uranium (DU) lying around to be absorbed by the temple of God?

Is it all right to deny health care to the temple of God?

Is is all right to stand by and watch tens of thousands of temples of God be destroyed by hunger, disease, war, or--for that matter--by bureaucratic policies?

Is it all right to lay of thousands of God's temples in order to preserve the over-inflated paycheck of one CEO (or even a dozen top officers)?

Note: the word "you" in the Greek text of these verses is plural. This temple of God bit is not about private individualized spiritual experiences. It is about us all.

Jesus went out again beside the lake; the whole crowd gathered around him, and he taught them. As he was walking along, he saw Levi son of Alphaeus sitting at the tax booth, and he said to him, ‘Follow me.’ And he got up and followed him.

And as he sat at dinner in Levi’s house, many tax-collectors and sinners were also sitting with Jesus and his disciples—for there were many who followed him. When the scribes of the Pharisees saw that he was eating with sinners and tax-collectors, they said to his disciples, ‘Why does he eat with tax-collectors and sinners?’ When Jesus heard this, he said to them, ‘Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick; I have come to call not the righteous but sinners.’

Now John’s disciples and the Pharisees were fasting; and people came and said to him, ‘Why do John’s disciples and the disciples of the Pharisees fast, but your disciples do not fast?’

Jesus said to them, ‘The wedding-guests cannot fast while the bridegroom is with them, can they? As long as they have the bridegroom with them, they cannot fast. The days will come when the bridegroom is taken away from them, and then they will fast on that day.

‘No one sews a piece of unshrunk cloth on an old cloak; otherwise, the patch pulls away from it, the new from the old, and a worse tear is made. And no one puts new wine into old wineskins; otherwise, the wine will burst the skins, and the wine is lost, and so are the skins; but one puts new wine into fresh wineskins.’ (Mark 2:13-22)
The concept of an Anglican Covenant is an old wineskin, if you ask me (which you didn't, I know). I have no doubt that Jesus hung out with disreputable persons. I find attempts to preserve purity both unconvincing and blasphemous. God sanctifies as God wills and all God makes is holy. It may get tarnished and twisted and need to be restored to its intended purpose but God does not abandon it. God is an adequate defender of God's own self. Our task is to share God's love and invite others into a transforming experience. God will handle the transforming. I do not need to make anyone conform to my concept of what God wants to do with him or her. I do not need to have everyone look, think, or act alike--a gross blasphemy against the creative variety God displays.

Because the Collects I put at the end of these posts comes from Lesser Feasts and Fasts and are thus the collects appointed for the weekdays of Lent, they are the prayers of the Church to which I belong and may not express things with exactly the theology or tone I might choose if I were writing them. Today I feel led to comment. I do not believe in spirit-matter dualism. They are two sides of one created reality. (Yes, the Holy Spirit is uncreated but I am not talking about the divine exception.) To me it is rather like matter and energy: we do not yet know of one without the other. Or the wave-particle nature of light. I thus cannot feel comfortable with assigning them a hierarchy. (I am no Platonist.) Spirit and flesh are both to be subject to God, in tandem, harmonized. So I post this prayer but I cannot honestly pray the part about subduing flesh to spirit. Both need sanctification equally, neither is prior to the other. I am an incarnational thinker who takes a very Genesis view of "nefesh" (the clay and breath--matter and spirit--together make the living soul--souls are not discarnate).

Lord Christ, our eternal Redeemer, grant us such fellowship in your sufferings, that, filled with your Holy Spirit, we may subdue the flesh to the spirit, and the spirit to you, and at the last attain to the glory of your resurrection; who live and reign with the Father and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.
--the BB

Lies, Liars, and FISA


Mcjoan discusses Director of National Intelligence Mike McConnell's baldfaced lies on the editorial page of the Washington Post. Do not expect the WashRag to note that they are publishing unquestioned White House propaganda.

Glenn Greenwald posted info yesterday that reminds us that the WH is blowing smoke up our asses.

The White House assumes (1) no one will fact check their statements, (2) no one will challenge them when they lie, (3) no one has a right to question them on anything--cf. the indignant Mme Rice who hates being caught in lies and takes it very personally--(4) the media will happily spread any bullshit they wish to propagate, and (5) Congress can't do anything about it because the WH will not recognize congressional oversight or cooperate with it on any level whatsoever.

Bush and sundry WH spokesliars have mongered fear so long folks are beginning to realize there is no substance to it (boy crying wolf syndrome). Scarecrow writes about this and the House Dems calling the bluff and not passing what Bush wanted. Bush immediately went on the offensive (I heard his words on the radio yesterday and once again went apoplectic while driving). Bush's dilemma is there is no crisis over this. Unless you count the threat that if Congress does NOT grant telcom immunity it may ultimately help reveal the extent of the White House's lawbreaking. That is what motivates Bush, not the threat of terrorists. He, in fact, is the force behind most terrorizing of the American people. In saying that I do not ignore or minimize the threat real terrorists pose to the world's peace and safety.

Scarecrow has lots of links to follow for more and also concludes thus:
The political battle is now clearly defined. The Republicans will claim that the nation faces imminent terror threats that the Democrats are unwilling either to acknowledge or defend against. The WH's Perino will claim Democrats are caving in to the "fantasies of left wing bloggers." Greenwald has more.

The Democrats will paint John "torture-is-okay-if-the-CIA-does-it" McCain as Bush/Cheney Act III, unprincipled fear mongers who not only mismanaged the effort against real terrorist threats by becoming bogged down in an unnecessary and costly Iraq invasion but also manipulated the terrorists' psychology to expand executive power at the expense of American freedoms.

It is an ageless fight. The campaign is on.

--the BB

Baptism: the Friday Five


The RevGals Friday Five is about baptism this week. I saw it at Diane's and Wyldth1ng's blogs.

1. When and where were you baptized? Do you remember it? Know any interesting tidbits?
I was baptized through the First Baptist Church of Fresno by the Rev. Bernie G. Osterhouse in March 1957. The church did not yet have a baptistry, so the baptisms took place in the First Christian Church in downtown Fresno. Since I was almost 11 at the time I do remember scattered images of it. We are, of course, talking full immersion here, which I still believe is preferable (though not required) as it vividly expresses death, burial, and being raised again.

2. What's the most unexpected thing you've ever witnessed at a baptism?
In person I am not sure I have witnessed anything particularly unexpected. But the most spectacular baptism for me was the Sunday I baptized 18 persons across four generations from one family. They were Cambodian-Americans whose family had been sponsored by Bishop Bill Swing and the Episcopal Diocese of California when they came to California from the refugee camps in Thailand. Many had been baptized on Pentecost a couple of decades earlier in St Paul's, Oakland. Now most of the rest were finally baptized, including the patriarch and matriarch, some of their children, many of their grandchildren, and a couple of great-grandchildren. We flexed on the timing (it was neither Easter Day nor Pentecost but it was on a Sunday in Easter). I felt Resurrection everywhere I turned that day.

3. Does your congregation have any special traditions surrounding baptisms?
St Cuddy's had a restored ancient tradition of giving a spoonful of milk and honey to the neophytes.

4. Are you a godparent or baptismal sponsor? Have a story to tell?
Yes, though I am a fairly rotten godparent. I do keep them in my prayers but little else.

5. Do you have a favorite baptismal song or hymn?
At St Cuddy's we always sang Hymn # 296, "We know that Christ is raised and dies no more" (tune: Engelberg). I love the energy of that tune and the reference to Christ's Body taking on new flesh and blood (in the baptized).

--the BB

An uncharitable movie review

Here is what I wrote to a friend this morning about The Golden Compass movie that another friend and I watched yesterday afternoon:

The movie was somewhat interesting but actually rather disappointing. "Thin" is the term I applied. I think they were trying to cover tons of Pullman's plot in this unusual world in a short period of time and there was thus no allowance for much in the way of developing character or giving either the persons or the world any depth. Lots of scenery and costumes and action. Very "American" as opposed to a "European" film that would move slowly and allow people and circumstances to "ripen." Extremely sketchy and not much opportunity for an actor to do subtlety.

While the issue of a Magisterium that wants to remove free will and inquiry is quite clear, it does not seem in the least religious and we know Pullman parallels it intentionally with religion, even using a term for the teaching authority of the Catholic Church. There is no element of ritual and that, for me, totally destroys any sense that the Magisterium should be paralleled with or equated to religion. It is just more like Stalin or Orwellian thought police.

In fact, for all the "magical" elements in the tale it does not seem to have any magic to it. It is short on awe and, though loyalty and bravery are big there is little of what one might consider compassion or larger vision. I would use the term heartless. Even the "good" characters seem to operate with very little or no "heart." Call me a sentimental fool, but it is difficult to imagine the characters in the film as being capable of love. Sympathy, loyalty, finding someone else's lot pitiable, yes... but not love.

There is no unifying vision. "Dust" connects parallel worlds and the Magisterium suppresses knowledge of it, but the sense, critical to mystics and to compassion, that all things and creatures are linked, of a web of life--utterly missing. Or at least it does not come through to me in this film.

It is very dark, literally (cinematography, lighting, costumes).

The characters are intriguing and one wants to know more about them.

Lots of effort, lots of visual texture (though little of any other kind), lots of effects, a crap film.

[All this is through the eye of someone writing fantasy fiction with a great deal of energy spent on character, relationships, motivations, and a coherent world with cultures that seem believable--well, that's my aim, I cannot guarantee results. This is probably why I was so disappointed in not finding much in the way of what I care so much about.]
--the BB

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Thursday in Lent 1

When Jesus saw their faith, he said to the paralytic, ‘Son, your sins are forgiven.’ (Mark 2:5)

And so, brothers and sisters, I could not speak to you as spiritual people, but rather as people of the flesh, as infants in Christ. I fed you with milk, not solid food, for you were not ready for solid food. Even now you are still not ready, for you are still of the flesh. For as long as there is jealousy and quarrelling among you, are you not of the flesh, and behaving according to human inclinations? For when one says, ‘I belong to Paul’, and another, ‘I belong to Apollos’, are you not merely human? (1 Corinthians 3:1-4)

God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble. Therefore we will not fear, though the earth be moved, and though the mountains be toppled into the depths of the sea; Though its waters rage and foam, and though the mountains tremble at its tumult. (Psalm 46:1-3, BCP)
I was struck, in a new way, by the story of Potiphar's wife and young Joseph. When she couldn't commit adultery with the young Hebrew stud, she made false accusations and he landed in prison.

I cannot avoid political overtones these days. Not getting one's way and / or lying seem to be prominent themes in Washington, DC, at the moment.

But that is not what struck me. It was, instead, a reversal from the usual context in which "No" means "No." In te story of Joseph recorded in Genesis, Joseph keeps his healthy boundaries, his integrity, and his master's honor intact by saying "No." Potiphar's wife refuse to accept his healthy boundaries, transgressing several she should have in the process. Even when Joseph removes himself from the scene, she takes advantage of it to exact revenge for her perceived slight.

Men who "want one thing" are notoriously dense on the subject of what "No" means. The joke is "What part of 'No' don't you understand?" The retort would seem to be "all of it."

For the sake of good boundaries, healthy relationships, and the good of all, we need to learn how to say "No" and how to hear it. All of us, regardless of gender or any other category.
Strengthen us, O Lord, by your grace, that in your might we may overcome all spiritual enemies, and with pure hearts serve you; through Jesus Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.
--the BB

KO--my hero


Keith Olbermann dropped the F-bomb on Bush tonight:
If you believe in the seamless mutuality of government and big business — come out and say it!

There is a dictionary definition, one word that describes that toxic blend.

You’re a fascist — get them to print you a t-shirt with “fascist” on it!

What else is this but fascism?
He also uttered the L-word.
And if there’s one thing we know about Big Brother, Mr. Bush, is that he is — you are — a liar.

Not that one can be a sentient being and NOT know that George Weasel Walker Bush is a liar.

Read, or watch, it all at Crooks and Liars.
--the BB

We report; you decide

The question: does John McCain oppose torture or not?

I used to think the question was fairly clear cut.

Maybe not.

Check the story. Weigh in.

I do not consider it a good thing that we should even wonder.
--the BB

What's House Judiciary up to?

This afternoon, the House of Representatives voted to hold White House Chief of Staff Joshua Bolten and former White House Counsel (and one-time Supreme Court nominee) Harriet Miers in contempt of Congress for their refusal to testify about the White House role in the purge.
--David Kurtz

Josh Marshal has some comments:
With torture debates and the raucous presidential primaries, folks don't think much anymore about the US Attorney scandal and the Bush administration political purge of the DOJ that led eventual to multiple resignations and the fall and disgrace of Alberto Gonzales, President Bush's Attorney and long-time legal confidant. But that's what these contempt citations are about. They're aimed at finally pushing through the stonewalling that the White House has now used for more than a year to keep the truth of what happened from becoming known.

More

--the BB

Running behind today

Good evening, my valentines, visitantes, and visionaries. I was up late last night and thus arose late this morning. Then I ran off to see Golden Compass with a friend, followed by supper at Village Pizza in Corrales (pepperoni and green chile--this IS New Mexico, land of Hatch chiles and slow vote counts).

I will keep my daily discipline for Lent but in a little while. For now....


Senator Harry Reid and Congressman Silvestre Reyes both sent Valentine letters to Bush, basically telling him to put a sock in it (or was that shove it somewhere?). About time someone told him to.

Amongst other comments, Reid wrote this:
Your opposition to an extension is inexplicable. Just last week, Director of National Intelligence McConnell and Attorney General Mukasey wrote to Congress that "it is critical that the authorities contained in the Protect America Act not be allowed to expire." Similarly, House Minority Leader Boehner has said "allowing the Protect America Act to expire would undermine our national security and endanger American lives, and that is unacceptable." And you yourself said at the White House today: "There is really no excuse for letting this critical legislation expire." I agree.

Nonetheless, you have chosen to let the Protect America Act expire. You bear responsibility for any intelligence collection gap that may result.

Fortunately, your decision to allow the Protect America Act to expire does not, in reality, threaten the safety of Americans. As you are well aware, existing surveillance orders under that law remain in effect for an additional year, and the 1978 FISA law itself remains available for new surveillance orders. Your suggestion that the law's expiration would prevent intelligence agents from listening to the conversations of terrorists is utterly false.
[Emphasis mine. Note the genteel wording in which Reid calls Bush a liar, which, of course, he is.]

Reyes wrote this:
Because I care so deeply about protecting our country, I take strong offense to your suggestion in recent days that the country will be vulnerable to terrorist attack unless Congress immediately enacts legislation giving you broader powers to conduct warrantless surveillance of Americans' communications and provides legal immunity for telecommunications companies that participated in the Administration's warrantless surveillance program.

Today, the National Security Agency (NSA) has authority to conduct surveillance in at least three different ways, all of which provide strong capability to monitor the communications of possible terrorists.

It's about time someone threw facts back in the lying weasel's face. [Yes, now you know what the "W" stands for.]

You can read it all in mcjoan's post at Daily Kos. Kagro X reminds us all that if you quote the President be sure to note that he's lying (always a good policy).

Mcjoan also points out that the world does not end when Dems do stand up to the chimperor:
The Democrats stood up to Bush, and the world didn't end. And I bet it felt really, really good. I know it did. I heard the raucous cheers on the House floor when Hoyer made that statement. Remember how good it feels, Dems, and keep at it.
It seems Keith Olbermann may have ended his special comment with this:
We will not fear George W. Bush, nor fear because George W. Bush wants us to fear.


On that happy note, to borrow from Garrison Keillor on "The Writer's Almanac":
Be well, do good work, and keep in touch.
--the BB

Pseudopiskie started it this time




Based on my total resistance to scheduling....
--the BB

Cyril and Methodius, brothers and saints

Photo source here

My blogging chums are all over this, so do visit Deacon Ormonde Plater and Padre Mickey for all manner of learned and godly material on these splendid chaps. Grandmère Mimi has comments as well.

I would only highlight their use of local language and customs in their evangelization. They did not impose Latin (as Frankish missionaries were wont to do). Ever since learning about them in classes on Balkan history and early Church history, they have been to me saints of plurality within the Body of Christ.

Almighty and everlasting God, who by the power of the Holy Spirit moved your servant Cyril and his brother Methodius to bring the light of the Gospel to a hostile and divided people: Overcome all bitterness and strife among us by the love of Christ, and make us one united family under the banner of the Prince of Peace; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever.
-the BB

Boycotting Lambeth

I cannot, in our technological age, say that much ink has been spilled, but many bytes have wiggled their way through the intertubes on the issue of whether or not to attend Lambeth this year. Thinking Anglicans reports that Ugandan bishops will not be going.
[Archbishop Henry Orombi] added that their non-attendance was a means of expressing their disapproval that American bishops have been invited to the ten-yearly gathering of Primates. He said: “This decision has been made to protest the invitations extended by the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Most Rev Rowan Williams, to TEC Bishops whose stand and unrepentant actions created the current crisis of identity and authority in the Anglican Communion.” He added they planned to meet with other traditionalist bishops at an ‘alternative Lambeth’ called the Global Anglican Future Conference (GAFCON) in Jerusalem in June, which is expected to be attended by other conservative leaders from Africa and Australia.
The whole bit about "I won't come if so-and-so is coming" is not attractive even among those in their early teens. It is most unbecoming and immature among adults.

While some individual bishops have not been invited, all the Anglican provinces have been. It is an opportunity to see each other face-to-face, share our common humanity, get to know each other, learn about each other's contexts, and engage in dialogue. In shared humanity and dialogue there is opportunity to promote understanding and lessen tension. New ways to move forward together might be discovered. If not, at least new or renewed ties of fellowship might enable journeying, in both tension and charity, as we seek to follow our one Lord.

If you won't let me sit at your table and won't sit at a table where you and I are both invited, you may certainly do so. But that is your choice and, in the latter case, you were not excluded, so don't go crying about being excluded. You stayed home and pouted; you are welcome to your pout. Cherish your misery and indignation. But do not expect a scintilla of sympathy.

Those who clearly want their own party with their own rules about who gets in the door and sits at the table can bloody well throw their own party. They should send out their announcements to the chosen few and have their fun, but please just STFU about victimization and martyrdom until and unless the rest of us actually start burning you at the stake.

Btw, the more you carry on the more tempting that is but I don't want to waste good wood.

And do not, under any circumstances, steal the property on your way out the door. You may think you are the new Moses leading the Israelites out of Egypt and we should be glad to give you our gold as you leave but you're not and we're not, so get over it.
--the BB

John Locke weighs in on the Anglican Covenant

Photo of Locke from here

John Locke, for "A Letter Concerning Toleration" (1690):

". . .I esteem that Toleration [mutually among Christians] to be the chief Characteristical Mark of the True Church. For whatsoever some People boast of the Antiquity of Places and Names, or of the Pomp of their Outward Worship; Others, of the Reformation of their Discipline; All, of the Orthodoxy of their Faith; (for every one is Orthodox to himself). These things, and all others of this nature, are much rather Marks of Men striving for Power and Empire over one another, than of the Church of Christ. Let any one have never so true a Claim to all these things, yet if he be destitute of Charity, Meekness, and Good-will in general towards all Mankind, even to those that are not Christians, he is certainly yet short of being a true Christian himself."

""It is not the diversity of Opinions, (which cannot be avoided) but the refusal of Toleration to those that are of different Opinions, (which might have been granted) that has produced all the Bustles and Wars, that have been in the Christian World upon account of Religion."

(Hat tip again, to Turner and Quinn)


The above is lifted in toto from The Lead at Episcopal Cafe. Many thanks to Jim Naughton and the Turner and Quinn philosophical archaeology team!

They are, of course, trying to reintroduce Reason into Anglican discourse. This, for the sola Scriptura crowd, is anathema, to which I say: "You want sola Scriptura? Become Lutheran." Hooker--with his triple cord of Scripture, tradition, and reason--would be horrified at much that claims to be "Anglican" these days.
--the BB

Holy Valentinus, pray for us

That our hearts may be tender,
yet not so defenseless as to be easily crushed;

that our hearts be strong,

yet not hardened and inflexible;

that our hearts be open
to all that is good and kind and noble

yet firm against cruelty and thoughtlessness;

swift to forgive and slow to anger;

wise and prudent in all our dealings

lest we descend to folly

yet ever willing to be fools for God

in the eyes of an unknowing world.

May our hearts never close themselves

to love or to kindness.

In their breaking

may they become whole.



--the BB

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Lordy, I tire of bringing updates; I do.

If you're looking for charity, don't come here. I've had it with people in power who lack decency, morals, or a lick of common sense and I'm in no mood for nicey nice.
It would seem that Senator John Warner no longer has the sense God gave a goose, as my mother would have said. He actually asserted on the Senate floor today that because the telcoms volunteered they should be granted immunity. Let me get this clear. If I volunteer to break the law, then I should be granted immunity for breaking the law.

On what planet does that make sense? Would someone please send him there, because he isn't being helpful on this one.

Kagro X writes about it here.
We have a Justice of the United States Supreme Court getting all soft on torture. Yes, Nino Ratf**k Scalia is out there saying things like this:
SCALIA: Is it really so easy to determine that smacking someone in the face to find out where he has hidden the bomb that is about to blow up Los Angeles is prohibited under the Constitution? Because smacking someone in the face would violate the 8th amendment in a prison context. You can’t go around smacking people about. Is it obvious that what can’t be done for punishment can’t be done to exact information that is crucial to this society? It’s not at all an easy question, to tell you the truth...
[Emphasis mine]
Torture not an easy question? Let me help you, s**t-for-brains: Torture is not acceptable EVER. End of discussion. Would you please go duck hunting with Dick Cheney. Maybe he can "pepper" some sense into you.

Smintheus writes about the disgusting slimeball here.

Mcjoan shares a statement from Speaker Pelosi that points out we are NOT in crisis mode over FISA legislation (no matter how much Pres. Pissypants stamps his feet):
All Members of Congress fully understand and support our responsibility to protect the American people and the need for the President, the Congress, and policymakers to have the best possible intelligence to fight terrorism.

On Friday, a surveillance law insisted upon by the President last August will expire. Today, an overwhelming majority of House Democrats voted to extend that law for three weeks so that agreement could be reached with the Senate on a better version of that law. The President and House Republicans refused to support the extension and therefore will bear the responsibility should any adverse national consequences result.

However, even if the Protect America Act expires later this week, the American people can be confident that our country remains safe and strong. Every order entered under the law can remain in effect for 12 months from the date it was issued.

Furthermore, the underlying Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, which provides for the surveillance of terrorists and provides that in emergencies surveillance can begin without warrant, remains intact and available to our intelligence agencies. Unlike last August, the FISA court has no backlog of cases, and thus can issue necessary court orders for surveillance immediately.

Want to pressure some Blue Dog Dems? Mcjoan has the contact info here.


Kagro X discusses the issue of criminal contempt of Congress here. As Kagro X discusses, Rahm Emmanuel's point about the risk of an adverse court decision is real but certainly no greater a risk than doing nothing.
Here, it might be time to borrow a page from the White House playbook, and pursue a "flood the zone" strategy. When the White House has multiple outrages to perpetrate (as is so often the case), it does so in overwhelming waves, with no mind paid to pacing or any insistence on decent intervals in between. Indeed, the strategy seems to be to flood the public, the media, and the Democratic opposition with everything it can throw at them, all at once. And each time they've done it, the national media have been for the most part unable (or uninterested) in keeping up. Light five fires at once, and four go relatively unnoticed.

So perhaps it's time to bring out all the grievances against the executive now roiling beneath the surface inside the Congress. Why not deal with contempt at the same time as we (hopefully) fight on FISA? And why not encourage the Senate to add its pending contempt votes to the pile as well? And why not get down to issuing subpoenas aimed at the "administration's" stonewalling on questions surrounding the missing e-mails? The destruction of the torture tapes? The withholding of key documents and testimony by the Department of Education? By NASA? In fact, by virtually every department of the executive branch that's been asked to comply with Congressional oversight over the past several years?

If George W. Bush's judiciary is ready to validate all of this, perhaps that's something the public would like to know, heading into the next election. Let's get at least some of this -- the most egregious parts, anyway -- out on the table.

Let's face it, something's got to be on that table.

Bonddad simply says (with reference to the Fourth Amendment): "To Congress: You Suck."
Clammyc has a message for Senator Schumer:
Allowing for retroactive immunity in a FISA bill that had no business even being brought to the floor is not progressive. Folding to Mister Bush on Iraq over and over and over when the vast majority of the country is on your side is not progressive. Sending a big "F-You" to MoveOn.org on the Senate floor is not progressive. Allowing extremist appointment after extremist appointment by Bush is not progressive. Caving to an unpopular President and an even less popular Congressional minority is not progressive. Allowing non-progressives to continuously set the tone of the debate is not progressive.


John Aravosis says this:
The surveillance law is so important that they're trying to kill it, in order to prove how important it really is. Now who doesn't care about catching Osama? Then again, these are the same people who haven't caught Osama in 7 years, and don't really seem all that interested in doing so.
John also talks about some anti-torture legislation:
Today, McCain voted with those opposing the Intelligence bill because it uses the Army Field Manual (something he used to support) to effectively outlaw torture (something he used to oppose). In the end, McCain lost and we won. The Senate passed the bill (vote count here) making the Army Field Manual the law of the land for the entire US government.


Emptywheel notes that "Conyers has gotten cranky." About time, say I.


Well, that's enough bitchin' for tonight. I try to keep y'all abreast of some things I think matter to us, big time, whether we pay attention to them or not.

Sleep well and get your strength up. We have lots of politicians to whack upside the head tomorrow. And the day after.
--the BB

Wexler tries to get Condi to admit what is known

I love hearing Condi Rice's integrity questioned. She gets so pissy. How she thinks anyone associated with George Bush has a shred of credibility is just amazing.

I have never believed a word she says.



"To claim ... there are things we hid is just not right."

Excuse me, there are reasons you are known as Condaliar! There is documentation that there are things they hid and the stack of it was sitting right there next to Wexler.

And, contrasted with Cheney and Rumsfeld, she's the "good cop" in our foreign policies. What a sad thing that is. Let's remember, she ignored the warnings leading up to 9/11. The whole lot of them are a waste of oxygen.
--the BB

Contempt and civil suits


Paul Kiel at TPM reports:
House Judiciary Committee Chair John Conyers (D-MI) introduced two resolutions this afternoon related to the subpoenas. The first is a criminal contempt resolution against White House chief of staff Josh Bolten and former White House counsel Harriet Miers -- both were subpoenaed and did not respond, citing the White House's invocation of executive privilege. But Conyers also filed a resolution that Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) file a civil suit against the White House.

Things could get interesting.
--the BB

There's a torture vote up in the Senate today

John Aravosis at Americablog:
The Senate is getting ready to vote on a key torture amendment today, making the Army field manual rules regarding torture apply to the entire government. At one point during the campaign McCain praised the Army field manual as the way to go - Life is not "24," McCain said at the time. So how will McCain vote today? Will he support the Army field manual? Will he oppose it? Or will he just blow off the vote entirely on one of his signature issues that he claims he cares so much about?
Emphasis mine. It would be great if this passed.
--the BB

Don't we all want retroactive immunity?--updated

Then we'd never have to worry about breaking laws. We wouldn't even need the Nuremburg Defense.
A screen cap from Daily Kos (click on image to enlarge).

Yes, this is another FISA update. (What? Again? Can't you let it rest, BB? Sorry; no.)

Bush is lying and fearmongering again (quelle surprise!).

21 Blue Dog Dems are busy fellating the President and I want photos for the tabloids, dammit. Rip the "D" off that stands behind their names and replace it with "WHT" (White House Tool). Useless twits. Worse than useless--they're damaging the Constitution and declaring they no longer believe in the rule of law.

How's this for a quote (via Christy at Firedoglake)?
There is a very real and perverse possibility that the NFL will face tougher sanctions for spying on practice squads and covering it up than the telecoms and this President will face for spying on the citizenry and lying about it.
More from Christy:
It isn't over. We are pushing members of the House to stand firm against telecom immunity -- please take a little time to sign the petition here. Have you called your Representative today?


From the same post, the ACLU has talking points for us:
1. Vote NO on any spying bill with telecom immunity. Lawsuits must be allowed to proceed or we’ll never know the truth about what laws were broken and how many Americans rights were violated.

2. Vote NO on any spying that allows the government to spy on Americans without getting a warrant. America doesn’t need a bill that needlessly expands the President’s ability to spy on innocent Americans without a warrant.

3. Don’t let the Senate or President Bush steamroll the House of Representatives. Any bill to regulate spying on Americans must respect the Constitution and must not let phone companies off the hook for warrantless spying.

And you can find your Representative's office here.

As Thom Hartmann says, Democracy begins with you. Tag, you're it.

UPDATE:
In case you ever doubted that they were doing what we've claimed / feared they were doing, Bush let it slip. From Raw Story:
Well, he finally dropped the "allegedly." President Bush at long last admitted what everyone has suspected for years -- the nation's telecommunications companies closely cooperated with the National Security Agency and his administration to implement large-scale spying on Americans.

Bush was praising the Senate for approving his long-sought update to a foreign surveillance law. Critics say the bill legalizes his warrantless wiretapping program, which was implemented outside the boundaries of the law, and frees phone and internet companies from any responsibility for violating customers' privacy.

"The senate bill also provides fair and just liability protections for companies that did the right thing and assisted in defending America, after the attacks of Sept. 11," Bush said.
You know where to find the rest of the story.
--the BB

Thanks, Manny!

I am lifting this comment on any proposed Anglican Covenant wholesale from The Lead at Episcopal Cafe:

Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) [dates corrected from original post] on Religious Covenants. From "What is Enlightenment?" (1784)


"But should not a society of clergymen, for example an ecclesiastical synod or a venerable presbytery (as the Dutch call it), be entitled to commit itself by oath to a certain unalterable set of doctrines, in order to secure for a time a constant guardianship over each of its members, and through them over the people? I reply that this is quite impossible. A contract of this kind, concluded with a view to preventing all further enlightenment of mankind for ever, is absolutely null and void, even it is is ratified by the supreme power, by Imperial Diets and the most solemn peace treaties. One age cannot enter into an alliance on oath to put the next age in a position where it would be impossible for it to extend and correct its knowledge, particularly on such important matters, or to make any progress whatsoever in enlightenment. This would be a crime against human nature, whose original destiny lies precisely in such progress. Later generations are thus perfectly entitled to dismiss these agreements as unauthorized and criminal."

Hat tip Fred Quinn and Prof. Frank M. Turner, John Hay Whitney Professor of History Director, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.
--the BB

Give yourself a break from my political rants


Stroll on over to Padre Mickey's Dance Party to learn about Absalom Jones, a slave who became a priest in the Episcopal Church. Great man, and Padre Mickey, as usual, shares lots of information about one more saint of our church.

Have you caught the snow pictures chez Caminante?

Or the poems, prayers, and musings of Tandaina at Snow on Roses?

Fr Mike F has been offline for a few days but until he gets going again, check out past posts rooted in the contemplative life at The Mercy Blog.

Nature walks with spectacular photos, not to mention food porn, from the Cunning Runt at Little Bang Theory.

And so much more, but I thought these might help restore your equilibrium this morning.

Then you can get your dander back up with Fran and Mimi and the political blogs and me. But for now, a Lenten pause.

UPDATE:
Don't forget to treat yourself to the wonderful words of the Blessed Oscar Romero at Acts of Hope (here and here).

UPDATE 2:
Jane R reminds me, quite rightly, that Mike F is not a "father" though he is a dad.  My apologies.
--the BB

A Hallmark moment for the U. S. Senate


Folks, depression is anger turned inward. Let's not do that to ourselves. Send your anger where it belongs. Let the Senators know how you feel about betrayal of the Constitution, about betrayal of what America stands for, about betrayal of Us the People.

Especially if one or both of your Senators is a Dem who caved.

Be polite but firm.

If you are writing letters to the editor, remember to keep it coherent, cogent, and civil but very, very clear.

How about a nice Valentine to Chairman Conyers of the Judicial Committee urging him to begin impeachment hearings (that's the first step)?

And to Speaker Pelosi, reminding her that when high crimes and misdemeanors occur impeachment is expected to be on the table, not off it. (Hell, on that alone I'd be pushing for her recall if I lived in her district. All her touted accomplishments are dust if we lose our Constitution, the one thing she is sworn to uphold.)

Love and kisses to all you Valentines out there!
--the BB

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Wednesday in Lent 1

Then Judah said to his brothers, ‘What profit is there if we kill our brother and conceal his blood? Come, let us sell him to the Ishmaelites, and not lay our hands on him, for he is our brother, our own flesh.’ And his brothers agreed. (Genesis 37:26-27)

You may recall that Judah is not Jacob’s firstborn son, but this tale explains how the tribe of Judah came to rule over the Israelites. In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king. Even so, among murderous brothers the one who sells into slavery is a nice guy.

Can you imagine doing family counseling for any of the folks in Genesis? Lord, have mercy!

Might, just maybe, the fact that we all follow this crucified Lord be a good starting point for getting along with each other in the Anglican Communion?
A leper came to him begging him, and kneeling he said to him, ‘If you choose, you can make me clean.’ Moved with pity, Jesus stretched out his hand and touched him, and said to him, ‘I do choose. Be made clean!’ (Mark 1:40-41)
Jesus' approach to the outcast is notable. 'Nuff said.

Bless us, O God, in this holy season, in which our hearts seek your help and healing; and so purify us by your discipline that we may grow in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, for ever and ever. Amen.
--the BB

FISA-related updates

Senator Chris Dodd:
"We’ve just sanctioned the single largest invasion of privacy in American history."

h/t to fatbyjhnsn who has links and info at Daily Kos.

Occam's hatchet had this to say (and much more):
It is beyond my comprehension how any senators who voted today in favor of the telco immunity provisions of the FISA can dare to claim that they represent the interests of their constituents. The only interests served by the passage of a bill granting immunity from civil damages for felonious violations of citizens' privacy are those of the corporations, NOT those of the individual citizens who make up any senator's state.

My own senator, Dianne Feinstein, ought to be ashamed of her vote today - although I know she is not, nor will she ever be.

Jim Webb's vote is hugely disappointing, and indefensible.

And Hillary Clinton's absence from the vote leaves me absolutely cold.

There are others, to be sure - and we must never forget who they are.

Because they, evidently, have forgotten who put them into office, and whose interests they are supposed to represent.

Rep. John Conyers, Chair of the House Judiciary Committee, sent a little valentine to White House Counsel Fred Fielding:
First, please provide access to all Members of the House Judiciary Committee those briefings and materials you have made available to 19 Members as of now. Currently, it is my understanding that the entire membership of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence and the Senate Committee on the Judiciary and the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence has been permitted to be “read in” to the TSP program. The only Committee of jurisdiction that has not been offered the same access is the House Judiciary Committee. This is unacceptable and serves little purpose but to impede our Members review of the program and understanding of your request for retroactive amnesty.

Second, please provide the Memorandum for Alberto R. Gonzales, Counsel to the President, and William J. Haynes, II, General Counsel Department of Defense, from John C. Yoo, Deputy Assistant Attorney General and Robert J. Delahunty, Special Counsel, Office of Legal Counsel, Re: Authority for Use of Military Force to Combat Terrorist Activities Within the United States. It is believed that this Memorandum is dated either October 17, 2001, or October 23, 2001. Based on the title of this document, and based on the contents of similar memoranda issued at roughly the same time, it appears that a substantial portion of this Memorandum provides a legal determination and analysis as to the nature and scope of the Presidential war powers to accomplish specific acts within the United States. Congress is entitled to know the executive branch’s interpretation of its constitutional powers.

Third, please provide copies of filings, correspondence or transcripts of colloquies with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court about TSP or other warrantless or other electronic surveillance programs, containing legal analysis, arguments, or decisions concerning the interpretation of FISA, the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution, the Authorization for the Use of Military Force enacted on September 18, 2001, or the President’s authority under Article II of the Constitution.

h/t to Emptywheel for that.
Glenn Greenwald, as usual, had lots to say today:
The Senate today -- led by Jay Rockefeller, enabled by Harry Reid, and with the active support of at least 12 (and probably more) Democrats, in conjunction with an as-always lockstep GOP caucus -- will vote to legalize warrantless spying on the telephone calls and emails of Americans, and will also provide full retroactive amnesty to lawbreaking telecoms, thus forever putting an end to any efforts to investigate and obtain a judicial ruling regarding the Bush administration's years-long illegal spying programs aimed at Americans. The long, hard efforts by AT&T, Verizon and their all-star, bipartisan cast of lobbyists to grease the wheels of the Senate -- led by former Bush 41 Attorney General William Barr and former Clinton Deputy Attorney General Jamie Gorelick -- are about to pay huge dividends, as such noble efforts invariably do with our political establishment.

It's worth taking a step back and recalling that all of this is the result of the December, 2005 story by the New York Times which first reported that the Bush administration was illegally spying on Americans for many years without warrants of any kind.
In an update he adds:
On a related note, The Washington Post's Dan Froomkin cites the primary justification for telecom amnesty -- that these companies were just doing what they were told by the Government -- and then asks rhetorically: "isn't that the very definition of a police state: that companies should do whatever the government asks, even if they know it's illegal?" I used to think that amnesty supporters held their position because they didn't understand this extremely simple point, but now I think that most of them have their position precisely because they do understand it. A lawless "police state" -- and that's the only term that can be used to describe what this bill creates -- is exactly what our political establishment desires.
[Emphasis mine]

Just so you know: today the Senate of the United States voted to throw the Fourth Amendment out the window and your right to privacy with it.
--the BB

Where's the passion? Among the Dems!

Devilstower had this tidbit for us at Daily Kos tonight:
Barack Obama didn't just beat Hillary in Virginia. He didn't just get more votes than John McCain. In "red" Virginia, Obama got 142,000 more votes than all the Republicans put together. And that was with Hillary Clinton taking 100,000 more votes than John McCain.
You know how nasty a wild animal can get when threatened, not to mention cornered? I would beware of Republicans this year. It could get really nasty.
--the BB

A phony milestone

This blog has acrually been around since November 18. 2004. It was quite a while before I added a site meter. It seemed to cease working and it was quite a while before I then did something about it. Finally I launched a new, still free, site meter, last October.

This evening while I was off at Russian class at UNM we had the ten thousandth page view since that meter began clicking y'all off (which is so much nicer than ticking y'all off). That's not the total of unique visitors or anything, and it really has nothing to do with visits since the inception of the blog.

Which makes me wonder why I am bothering to mention it. Guess it's that turning of the odometer thing; you can't help noticing.

Well, in any case, ten thousand thanks for all the cool peeps who drop by. Those of you who return more than once are especially sweet.
--the BB

Your afternoon Feingold - with Updates


Senator Russ Feingold tries to help the blind see:
Mr. President, some of my colleagues have argued that the telephone companies alleged to have cooperated with the program had a good faith belief that their actions were in accordance with the law. But there is an entirely separate statute, in addition to the certification provision, that already provides telephone companies with a precisely defined good faith defense. Under this provision, which is found in section 2520 of title 18, if the companies rely in good faith on a court order or other statutory or legislative authorization, they have a complete defense to liability. This is a generous defense, Mr. President. But as generous as it is, it is not unlimited. A court must find that the telephone company determined, in good faith, that there was a judicial, legislative, or statutory authorization for the requested assistance.

Mr. President, I also want to address the argument that retroactive immunity is necessary because the telephone companies can't defend themselves in court. When I hear this argument, I can't help thinking that this administration has staged the perfect crime. Enlist private companies to allegedly provide assistance in an illegal government program, then prevent any judicial inquiry into the program by claiming a privilege – the so-called "state secrets" privilege – that not only shields your own actions from scrutiny, but enables the companies to evade judicial scrutiny as well by claiming that they are defenseless. All the administration needs to get away with it is Congress's blessing.

Whack your senators upside the head until they pay attention.

h/t to Marcy Wheeler at Emptywheel

UPDATE:
Meanwhile, now that they've caved, let's turn out attention to the House.

Hey,

I just signed this petition to tell House Democrats to stand strong behind the RESTORE bill and not capitulate like the Senate did in the fight against giving George Bush and the telecom industry amnesty for their crimes and ever-greater unchecked powers.

Please join me by signing this petition:

http://action.firedoglake.com/page/petition/RestoreFISA/kvdib

Thanks!

You can check out Christy Hardin Smith's post at Firedoglake for more info and links.

UPDATE 2:
From TPM we get this:
Dodd: Up To House To Kill Telecom Immunity

Sen. Dodd (D-CT) says that if the final FISA bill contains retroactive immunity, he'll filibuster it. But he thinks the House is the best hope to stop the "single largest invasion of privacy in the history of the country."
--the BB

What Atrios said

I've tried to express this point a few ways, but I'm not yet sure I've managed to get it quite right. The media coverage of campaign 2000 was a complete horror show, and not just because of the War on Gore. Essentially, the media covered the campaign as if it was a reality show to determine who would be the new star in a prime time dramedy called "The Presidency." You should vote for the guy you want to see on the teevee regularly, the one who will keep you entertained and make you feel good inside. The idea that this was a rather important job with consequences never entered into it.

-Atrios
[Emphasis mine]

So, how do We the People keep the pressure up on the media NOT to keep doing this?
--the BB

41 folks that need to be replaced

Kagro X provides this update at Daily Kos:
In rejecting the Feinstein "exclusivity" amendment to the FISA revision considered on the Senate floor today -- an amendment that failed by a vote of 57 Ayes to 41 Noes, thanks to another "painless filibuster" of precisely the type we were promised would not be tolerated on this bill -- the Senate has voted to say that although they were passing a law governing surveillance, it was OK if the President decided that he really didn't like the law very much and wished to make up his own instead.

Exclusivity -- the purpose of the amendment that "failed" -- meant simply this: that the law they were passing was the law, and it was the governing authority for how surveillance could be conducted in America.

The Senate just rejected it, so that means that they're passing a law, but if a president decides later on that he thinks there's really some other controlling authority besides the law, that's OK.
As I was speculating earlier, might we not have been better off if the earth had opened up and swallowed all current office holders during the SOTU speech? Then we could start over again with a Constitution and new folks to uphold it.

WTF is with these "painless filibusters" where the Senate Majority Leader allows 41 folks to stymie legislation without actually forcing them to filibuster. If they are going to obstruct, goddammit, make them do it publicly and with real effort so the whole nation can see what assholes they are.

If things move forward as they are now likely to do, the President will have nothing standing in his way when he wants to play games and ignore laws. As Kagro X said in conclusion: "I don't know why these people come to work at all."

Oh, and here's a bit from Update 3 of mcjoan:
Dodd/Feingold on amnesty fails, 31-67. 67 Senators think telcos deserve more protection than U.S. citizens. Or the Constitution. Nice.

You may fill in your own expletives.
--the BB

"Still Broken" by A. J. Rossmiller

A. J. Rossmiller, a former Defense Intelligence Agency Iraq analyst who now writes at Americablog and other sites, has written a new book, Still Broken.

Here is one paragraph in a section where his group learns they are not expected to uncover anything actionable (i.e., just be governmental wankers 'cause we don't know what the feck we're doing or supposed to do):

It became apparent that our assignment was not the counterinsurgency mission we’d anticipated. To some extent we were set up as a new and unique group from DIA. Our leadership told us that we were the largest cohesive DIA group to deploy to Iraq, as previous volunteers had been sent to fill individual slots in a wide variety of operations. We were supposed to be the connection between the field and the DIA element in DC, and we had just spent months learning about the history of the insurgency, beneficial and ineffective COIN techniques, and the intricacies of Iraqi tribes, religious groups, militias, and political organizations. This knowledge was supposed to make us a crack team of area experts, able to assist action units in the front and support the Iraq team in the rear (back in Washington). We were geared up to apply social network theory, create a better understanding of the insurgency and its accelerants, use a variety of analytical tools that would help identify insurgents and pinpoint the most crucial members of various groups, and employ our strategic acumen to assist policymakers. We were the heavy hitters, DIA’s contribution to the Combined Intelligence Operations Center or CIOC (pronounced sy-ock) -- the hub for U.S. intelligence in Iraq. But when we settled in, we realized that there was basically no mission for us. . . .
I have enjoyed Alex's reporting on many issues. Here's hoping lots of peeps read his book.

Still Broken: A Recruit's Inside Account of Intelligence Failures, from Baghdad to the Pentagon

[Click the link immediately above to find the book on Amazon.]

Wake up, America. The emperor has no clothes.
--the BB

If I believed in damning people to the fires of hell....


Q Dana, is the White House at all concerned that some of the evidence of the confessions by many of these men may not be admissible because they were obtained through waterboarding, which the administration admitted to last week?

MS. PERINO: Kathleen, I'm not going to able to comment about the trial from this podium.


No comment.
--the BB

Get over it!

John Barrowman (Captain Jack on Torchwood) is a great guy (and a total dish). He's out, proud, partnered, and happy. He's also participating in a new campaign to combat homophobic bullying in schools. Good on him!

You can read about it at Andy Towle's place.
--the BB