Saturday, October 27, 2007

Weary of hysteria


I have been a fan of Simon and Garfunkel since their first album, Wednesday Morning, 3 AM, came out in October 1964 (and I was a freshman at Pomona College). While passing by albums at Costco last week I saw a 3-CD release of their music titled Old Friends.

Listening to music from my past is both comforting and disturbing, but mostly comforting. I had a very strange feeling creep over me, however, when listening through headphones at work to the following song, one I recognized upon hearing but had forgotten:

The sun is burning in the sky
Strands of clouds go slowly drifting by
In the park the lazy breeze
Are joining in the flowers, among the trees
And the sun burns in the sky

Now the sun is in the West
Little kids go home to take their rest
And the couples in the park
Are holdin' hands and waitin' for the dark
And the sun is in the West

Now the sun is sinking low
Children playin' know it's time to go
High above a spot appears
A little blossom blooms and then draws near
And the sun is sinking low

Now the sun has come to Earth
Shrouded in a mushroom cloud of death
Death comes in a blinding flash
Of hellish heat and leaves a smear of ash
And the sun has come to Earth

Now the sun has disappeared
All is darkness, anger, pain and fear
Twisted, sightless wrecks of men
Go groping on their knees and cry in pain
And the sun has disappeared


This, my younger friends, is the omnipresent sense of dread that hung over my generation, an awareness that nuclear holocaust could destroy the world and it COULD happen. We had no idea if there would be a future, though we hoped there would be. We were talking about the end of life on this planet, not a minor conflagration here and there.

Now demagogues and asshats (I am not sure one can distinguish the two but I am trying to keep it civil and this is the best I can do) are ranting about the threat of islamofascism [as if we didn't have enough christofascism right here at home to deal with] and trying to drum up hysteria among the general populace in order to
  1. garner votes [by being the shrillest and therefore the most aware of the threat???];
  2. keep us in a state of constant fear so we can be easily manipulated [cf. Naomi Wolf on this];
  3. justify all manner of stupidity and atrocity [Iraq, Abu Ghraib, Iran?];
  4. keep us distracted from real problems that actually affect most of us on a daily basis [healthcare, poverty, diminished earning power, bankruptcy, ineffective education, the raping of resources and poisoning of the environment, etc.] and are caused or exacerbated by deliberate policies that need to be changed or reversed. There may be more reasons, but I doubt any of them are good or in the interest of the American People or the rest of the world.

Where is the perspective? We once had thousands of intercontinental ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads aimed at us for decades. That was a threat.

Are terrorists a threat? Absolutely! Does this threat need to be faced, understood, analyzed, and dealt with? Yes! Can you wage a war on a strategy? Well, no. Which is why a "war on terror" is sheer nonsense.

Fearmongers, the Cheney-Bush crime organization chief among them, are trying to convince us, to "catapult the propaganda" to use Bush's words, that we are facing the biggest threat ever.

Bullshit.

As Bill Maher reminds us:
… At the Republican debate last week, Mike Huckabee said Islamofascism is the greatest threat we ever faced. Really? More than the Nazis and the Russians and the Redcoats?



He has a lot to say about putting things back into perspective. Check it out.


Let's return to sanity. Ratchet back the rhetoric of doom. And why don't we start a mass movement of laughing at demagogues when they say stupid things?

Btw, if Jesus told us not to spend time trying to figure out when he's coming back do you think he will be happy with people who try to hasten his return? You really don't want to piss him off, folks.

--the BB

2 comments:

June Butler said...

We had no idea if there would be a future, though we hoped there would be. We were talking about the end of life on this planet, not a minor conflagration here and there.

Paul, I feel that way today. There is still much to be gloomy about, but my main worry is not Islamofascism. We are killing off the fragile planet we share space on. The Bush maladministration is killing off the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. The nuclear threat remains.

But, if we are people of faith, we may lay claim to hope in the face of what looks like hopelessness.

Paul said...

Indeed, Grandmère, it is difficult not to feel as though TEOTWAWKI lies just around the corner, even more so so long as Dick Cheney has any influence whatsoever. As I wrote this post I thought of our prior dread of nuclear destruction and how dread of global warming and its effects now permeates the thought of those with a modicum of awareness.

We have not escaped the nucelar threat by any means and Bush's reneging on long-standing treaties certainly hasn't helped. The use of bunker-busting bombs with depleted uranium means that carcinogenic radioactivity remains to destroy those we don't kill on the first pass. You note the destruction of our Constitution. Sigh.

The proper use of apocalyptic material is not terrifying people in order to manipulate them but to reassure them in their witness to truth. Let us then change our minds and change our course where we need to (repent) and hold fast to the truth we have come to know, certain in the faith that the will to power (the way of Caesar/antichrist) is not the ultimate force or value in this universe. Jesus taught us better than that.

Cyberhug!